The Macedonian Tendency: Kosovo - the illegal 'independence movement'

Wednesday, December 12, 2007

Kosovo - the illegal 'independence movement'

By Michael Nesonica

Since the beginning of the break-up of the former Yugoslavia in the early 90's one has pondered how far it would eventually go. Milosevic held onto the dream of 'Greater Serbia' with the facade of Yugoslavia but now it is the Serbs who are paying the price for his ultra nationalist stance. Let's not kid ourselves the war in the former Yugoslavia was not about ancient hatreds, it was concerned with politics and economics and the lack of progress. Slovenia and to a lesser extent Croatia were tired of 'carrying' the Yugoslav economy. The politicians particularly Tudjman and Milosevic used the situation to stir up nationalist sentiment and promote their own causes through such an avenue. Fear was the tool used to preach the message of nationalism and turn neighbours upon one another after years of living together with the only recorded 'ancient hatred' to speak of being the Ustasa slaughters of Serbs, Bosnians during World War II. In a place full of historic symbolism and allusions to past empires long gone the lure of nationalist sentiment has proved to be far to incendiary than what anyone was prepared for. What does any of this have to do with Kosovo one may ponder? Well it is simple really, you only need to look to the early 90s to see what carnage division brought about in the name of nationalism. Kosovo is the pawn in Albanians dreams for a 'Greater Albania' that will one day seek to envelop parts of Macedonia and Greece with nostalgia justified in the context of ancient Illyria and modern Albanians claims to be the direct descendants of these people.

After reading a few news stories from the BBC, and various reader comments I found myself bemused as to why the West (EU, NATO & US) would be in favour and indeed allow Kosovo to delcare independence.

Anti-Islam or anti-Europe, which is it?
The US claims to fight Islamic terrorism yet is supporting the creation of an Islamic state in Europe? (Albania, Bosnia, Kosovo are known/reported training grounds for terrorists with links to the Middle East). The Albanians have no need for peace, they move to neighbouring territories ie. Kosovo, the Republic of Macedonia, Greece and multiply to one day become the majority and secede. It is primitive thinking but with the backing of the West it works. To set up Kosovo as independent is not only immoral it is also illegal.
A dangerous precedent shall be set
The West created the majority of problems in the Balkans with their farcical 'map drawings' yet they still have not learnt have they. The Treaty of Bucharest 1913 comes to mind of course!If Kosovo becomes independent that inadvertently or not sets a precedent for the Albanians in the Republic of Macedonia and in Greece to seek/declare their own independence in the areas where they are a majority. Furthermore it will set a precedent whereby the EU, NATO and UN will have to accept Basque and/or Catalonian independence as well as that of the Silesian minority in Poland and the Czech Republic. How about the Serbs in the Republika Srpska in Bosnia? (They too will demand independence, you can't have double standards now can you? Oh wait we are talking about the West, double-standards are the status quo). I ask the question does this mean the Macedonian minorities in today's Greece(occupied Aegean Macedonia) and Bulgaria (occupied Pirin Macedonia) can now set-up there own independent state? No it doesn't. Yet international law applies for them, but not for the Albanians as the West supports the development of Islam in Europe. Obviously the Ottoman occupation didn't teach the West well enough, of course it wasn't the West but the Balkans who took the brunt of Islamic expansionism in the past. Maybe the West need another dose of economic, cultural and religious stagnation to clear their mind... Perhaps when Islam is on the doorstep of Britain, France, Germany and the Netherlands they will think differently? Oh but wait, Islam is already encroaching in these lands yet the West still has not taken heed from the lessons supposedly learnt in their own backyards. Congratulations to the West! Invite the scourge of Islam into Europe a little more cordially if it is possible! By supporting the independence of Kosovo the West merely rubberstamps the Albanians irredentist policy.

The Albanians have a state of their own, they should go back to it. They can claim all they like to be descendants of the Illyrians but so far no one is convinced, it is all hearsay. Albania was created by Italy and Austria with the dissolution of the Ottoman Empire to block Serb aspirations towards the coastline. Ironic now how it has all come to bite the Serbs in the rear-end as has the Serbs 'faith' in their ally Greece, who has sent them a Trojan Horse in the name of friendship as their stance on Kosovo has now changed with a concession made regarding the name dispute with Macedonia by the EU if reports are to be believed.

Here are a number of comments from the BBC website regarding Kosovo independence.

Monday, 10 December, 2007, 11:59 GMT 11:59 UK
We should not be overseeing the break up of countries under the auspices of the UN. This kind of thing was the mistake the old Imperial powers used to make - redrawing lines on maps. These steps were taken against 'ethnic cleansing' but did you know that Albanians are now in the majority because Serbs were ethnically cleansed from Kosovo at the end of the 19th century?If we allow this then expect your countries to be broken up on ethnic grounds as a result of mass immigration in the future.
Steve, Rochester

Steve, nice to see some people know their history, and the pivotal back-stabbing the West continues to ply while they try to play peacemaker!

Tuesday, 11 December, 2007, 06:09 GMT 06:09 UKKosovo is just a Serbian province that received lots of immigrants from Albania! It´s never been a Yugoslavian republic!! Nobody is even thinking about giving one inch to Serbia!!Yes!! Let´s all repeat the same mistake again! Let´s give Czechoslovakia to Hitler again!Remember: both World Wars also started by a western tyranic power attacking a smaller Slavonic eastern european country!!Now it´s all Nato agains little Serbia!! Jesus Christ!!Have you all gone mad??just to have a taste of revenge?
João Alcides Olenski, Curitiba - Brazil

Nice to know that the people of Brazil are not just interested in football but also see the injustices of the world forced upon smaller nations by the West. João you are a credit to your people.

Tuesday, 11 December, 2007, 07:51 GMT 07:51UK
Unfortunately what comes out from too many of the comments is a polarisation of views fuelled largely by feelings of nationalism. The sooner Albania, Serbia and Kosovo become members of the EU the sooner more people will realise that traditional geographic boundaries matter less and less, and that our collective future development is more important than the past. Improved economic stability encouraging investment and prosperity will benefit those concerned much more than historic predjudices.
mike, athens, greece

Oh Mike from Athens, you have really put your foot in it. This is quite rich coming from someone in Greece considering your nation's illogical determination to deny ethnic Macedonians their identity! (If you are indeed a 'pure' Greek that is - is there any other kind of Greek!)

Monday, 10 December, 2007, 10:26 GMT 10:26 UK
I don't think anything short of independence is a viable solution. Firstly all of you who stricken from the greater Albania phobia are extremely wrong. Albanians and Kosovars alike have no interest in this. Secondly after what Kosovars suffered in 98-99 at the hands of the Serb army and paramilitaries there is no way they can accept to go back again to their prior status. Lastly if all the former Yugoslavia republics managed to break away then so should Kosovo.
irvin kalakulla, Brussels, Belgium

One problem here Irvin, Kosovo was never a former Yugoslavian republic! What the Albanians suffered was a result of their irredentist attitude towards Serbia. You seem to forget that it was the Serbs who were once the majority in Kosovo and they were 'ethnically cleansed' from the area in the past.

Monday, 10 December, 2007, 10:17 GMT 10:17 UK
Giving Kosovo independence will set a VERY dangerous precedent - if them then why not Transdnistria, South Ossetia, Crimea, Repuplica Srpksa, Catalonia, Basque territoty ? Why not them ? And where will it end ? Surely Macedonia will be engulfed in blood and flames - as no doubt so too will Bosnia - our great leaders have unwisely taken us down a dangerous road.Taras Bulba, Odessa

Taras some words of wisdom, but remember what applies for the rest of the world does not apply to those in Washington, London or Brussels.

Tuesday, 11 December, 2007, 08:35 GMT 08:35 UK
Kosovo has been taken over by Albanian bullies. Why are all these Albanians not in Albania next door, which has been free for many years now. I feel so sorry for the Serbs who live there, and for those who have fled. The sins of Milosevic et al should not be visited on the Serbian people. I am extremely disappointed that NATO and EU are considering supporting the Kosovo Albanians' potential declaration of independence. It is not in my name and I am not happy about it.
Brontus Horace

Tuesday, 11 December, 2007, 07:54 GMT 07:54 UK
Kosovo is part of Serbia and the Albanians should return to their own country which is Albania.The Albanians were behaving in an anti-social manner when I visted Yugoslavia in 1970 by smashing the windscreens and windows of cars passing on the highway through the town of Pec Many innocent tourists had their windscreens smashed by these people whom they had done no harm.
don caskey, New Zealand

Nice to see some truth coming out about the 'innocent' Albanians of Kosovo!

Monday, 10 December, 2007, 10:03 GMT 10:03 UK
To Alice, Wonderland, EUYou couldn't have chosen a better nick!! Your opinion would really be more suitable for someone from a tale, and not from real life! If Albanians from Kosovo could live normally with Serbs, they wouldn't want to break away from Serbia. They considered the whole of Yugoslavia their exclusive property - Yugoslavia=Greater Serbia. That's why they can't accept it fell apart. Kosovo is only their most painful spot, but it's their problem. You reap what you sow.
Ivana, Čakovec, Croatia

Yes Ivana, the Serbs did consider Yugoslavia as Greater Serbia and theirs to do with as they pleased. But you neglect to mention that Yugoslavism or Illyrianism actually began in Croatia. It was a Croatian ideal, and the Croats wanted union with Serbia when they seceded from Austria-Hungary. The Croats were displeased that 'Yugoslavia' wasn't in their hands to control as they envisioned they would have a much greater say in what happened!

Monday, 10 December, 2007, 09:53 GMT 09:53 UK
Nothing I have seen over the last 10-15 years can convince me that the Serbian nationalists are a peace-loving movement. The West stood idly by during the last conflict, mostly because of British and UN inaction, while the Serbs massacred thousands of Croats. Serbia now threaten Kosovo over their independence. I say leave the Serbs to go down their own fascist road with the Russians, turning their back on democracy and reason. There is a new cold-war in the air.
ed stubbs, London

Ed, and Britain (aka England as that is essentially all it represnts) is the fountain of peace-loving nationalism! The Scots, Welsh and Irish all lost their culture and part of their identity due to British nationalism. Saying give Kosovo independence is like saying give London to an independent Scotland!


  1. Michael,

    You say that "what applies for the rest of the world does not apply to those in Washington, London or Brussels".

    Well, what part of the world you want Macedonia to belong to?

    Do you want to join the Russian federation or it is Iran a better deal for you?

    Kosovo just like Macedonia was left under Serbia in the beginning of the 20th century. Why do you want to deny to others what you have until now claimed for yourself?

    Macedonia is moving toward the West, whether people like you like it or not.

  2. Marco, Macedonia was left to not only Serbia, but Greece and Bulgaria at the beginning of the 20th century. Any who did that? It was a direct result of the West's imaginary map-drawings and division. Giving Kosovo independence is just another example of that.

    What am I denying others? The Albanians have Albania no one is denying them that, but their simple minded irredentist attitude to neighbouring states, territories I do deny that because they have no right to it. Nor should the West legitimize it.

    And Marco finally you have totally misunderstood what was said.
    The original quote is "Giving Kosovo independence will set a VERY dangerous precedent - if them then why not Transdnistria, South Ossetia, Crimea, Repuplica Srpksa, Catalonia, Basque territoty ? Why not them ? And where will it end ? Surely Macedonia will be engulfed in blood and flames - as no doubt so too will Bosnia - our great leaders have unwisely taken us down a dangerous road."
    Taras Bulba, Odessa

    So there you go Marco - Will Spain allow Catalonia, Basque territories to become independent? Will Britain allow Scottish and Welsh independence or allow Northern Ireland to join the Republic?
    Why should Macedonia join Russia or Iran, Macedonia should be left to itself to develop how it pleases. Yes they are leaning towards a Western orientated path, but I am merely pointing out the hypocrisy on the part of the West where they divide smaller nations on supposed self-determination grounds yet do not offer the same to the minorities with far more historical claims in their own lands.
    Whether you like it or not Marco, Kosovo does not belong to the Albanians or KOSOVARS as they like to call themselves.

  3. Read more about presentation of Republic of Kosovo before the International Court of Justice: Procedural Aspects